A Storied East Bay Residence Changes Hands in Charleston

At 55 East Bay Street in Charleston, along the stretch where the harborfront meets some of the city’s most photographed streetscapes, a late-18th-century townhouse has quietly transferred ownership. The property stands just steps from Rainbow Row and within sight of White Point Garden, placing it inside what was once the colonial fortified city — the small peninsula protected by defensive walls and bastions before they were removed in the early 19th century. (shown in image from 1937)

Constructed around 1785, the four-story masonry residence was commissioned by merchant Jonathan Simpson during Charleston’s recovery period following the American Revolution. The parcel itself traces to land holdings connected to the influential Pinckney family, whose properties formed part of the early waterfront mercantile district. At the time, East Bay Street functioned as Charleston’s commercial spine, lined with counting houses, shipping offices and residences belonging to traders tied to Atlantic commerce.

Architecturally, the home reflects the restrained proportions of late Georgian design adapted to the Lowcountry climate. High ceilings, thick masonry walls, tall sash windows and operable interior shutters allowed ventilation before mechanical cooling existed. Inside, significant historic material survives, including hand-crafted stair rails, heart-pine flooring, cypress paneling and paneled doors that would have been installed when the nation itself was only beginning.

Like many Charleston houses, the structure’s life mirrors the city’s economic cycles. After its original owner experienced financial hardship in the 1780s, the residence passed through several owners and by the 19th century was no longer a single-family dwelling. During the post-Civil War years it operated as a boarding house, a common fate for large peninsula residences as Charleston’s population shifted and fortunes declined.

Local preservation records also recount a more colorful chapter in the mid-20th century when the building briefly gained notoriety before authorities shut down the activity in the late 1950s. Not long afterward, Charleston’s emerging preservation movement began restoring historic residences, and the house was returned to private residential use. That period likely contributed to the survival of original interior details that might otherwise have been removed during heavier modernization eras.

The building sits on a deep lot unusually large for the historic district and includes a traditional rear dependency — once a detached kitchen structure to reduce fire risk and heat inside the main house. A modern connector now links the spaces while preserving their historic form. The rear building still contains oversized cooking hearths typical of 18th-century urban Charleston houses, when meals were prepared over open flame.

Among the home’s distinctive exterior features is a projecting marble balcony extending from the second level. Unlike the more common iron piazzas and galleries seen throughout the peninsula, the balcony is supported without visible brackets, a construction method rarely used locally and seldom preserved intact.

Inside, the vertical layout remains characteristic of early Charleston townhouses. Formal entertaining rooms occupy the lower floors, private chambers sit above, and the uppermost level captures views toward Charleston Harbor. The surrounding neighborhood reflects layers of Charleston history — from merchant wharves to private clubs and civic landmarks — all within a few blocks’ walk.

Today the residence stands as an example of how Charleston’s preservation efforts, which gained momentum in the mid-20th century and later influenced historic districts nationwide, protected buildings that might otherwise have been lost. Rather than appearing as a museum piece, the house continues to function as a private residence, illustrating the city’s unusual balance: an active modern community living inside a landscape shaped more than two centuries ago.

About the Author

Bryan Crabtree is a Charleston and Mount Pleasant, South Carolina real estate agent specializing in luxury homes, waterfront property, historic residences, and relocation buyers throughout the East Cooper and greater Charleston area. With more than two decades of experience and thousands of homes sold, he provides pricing strategy guidance, market analysis, and commentary on the Charleston housing market.

TheRealEstateExperts.com is Bryan Crabtree’s primary website and publishing platform, where he writes articles and local real estate analysis for buyers and sellers considering a move within the Charleston region.

Official profile: https://www.therealestateexperts.com/team/bryan-crabtree
Additional background information: https://bryancrabtreerealestate.com